Skip to main content
IRS-authorized e-file provider · not the IRS

Nonprofit · EIN 36-0879870

CATHOLIC ORDER OF FORESTERS

Also known as State Court of Massachusetts

Tax-exempt · NAPERVILLE, IL 60563

Financials

$168.5M$167.2M2023$105.8M$105.4M2024
Revenue Expenses · by fiscal year end
Financials of CATHOLIC ORDER OF FORESTERS by year, from its e-filed returns
Year endedFormRevenueExpensesNet incomeTotal assetsLiabilitiesNet assets
December 31, 2024990$105,771,852$105,444,291$327,561$1,212,528,934$1,152,315,256$60,213,678
December 31, 2023990$168,454,127$167,157,575$1,296,552$1,246,730,858$1,181,647,091$65,083,767
Financial details: 990 for the year ended December 31, 2024

Revenue

Contributions, gifts and grants
$0
Program service revenue
$49,457,249
Investment income
$56,110,047
Other revenue
$204,556

Expenses

Grants and similar amounts paid
$348,534
Benefits paid to members
$81,671,358
Compensation of officers, directors and key employees
$5,336,480
Other salaries and wages
$4,227,874
Salaries, compensation and benefits (total)
$11,954,071
Professional fundraising fees
$0
Legal fees
$77,825
Accounting fees
$72,975
Occupancy
$819,109
Travel
$502,535
Depreciation
$701,270

Balance sheet and other

Total assets, start of year
$1,246,730,858
Total assets, end of year
$1,212,528,934
Total liabilities, end of year
$1,152,315,256
Net assets, end of year
$60,213,678
Land, buildings and equipment
$6,573,509
Publicly traded securities
$975,746,330
Gross unrelated business income
$106,271
Gross receipts
$105,771,852
Employees
90
Volunteers
1,000
Year formed
1883
State of legal domicile
IL

From the e-filed returns the IRS publishes as XML (latest three processing years; amended returns replace the original). PDF copies at the IRS.

Officers, directors and key employees

As listed on the 990 for the year ended December 31, 2024, highest compensation first.

NameTitleHours / weekCompensation
Greg TemplePresident
Officer
40$746,704
Mark WalsworthEVP - Chief Marketing Officer
Officer
40$711,692
Christopher NowotarskiGeneral Counsel/Corporate Secretary
Officer
40$499,809
Joni KazmierczakVP
Key employee
40$294,052
Tim PowersDirector
Key employee
40$264,291
John HillebrandSVP
Officer
40$255,834
Michael DeeringVP
Key employee
40$246,315
Lawrence MillsVP
Key employee
40$206,044
Matt KorienekDirector of Business Development
Key employee
40$201,605
Nelson LundChief Actuary
Key employee
40$196,289
Holly NaumanDirector
Key employee
40$193,708
Matt TaylorSenior Field Manager
Highest-paid employee
40$181,068
Angela JordanChief Underwriter
Key employee
40$178,142
Rodney OligmuellerChairman of the Board/Trustee
Trustee or director
20$176,500
Wayne ShogerFacilities Engineer
Highest-paid employee
40$154,732
17 more people on this return
NameTitleHours / weekCompensation
Judy JamesVP
Highest-paid employee
40$145,148
Jerome SweeneyManager
Highest-paid employee
40$135,865
Thomas HummelFinancial Reporting Manager
Highest-paid employee
40$133,569
Ronald FreundVice High Chief Ranger/Trustee
Trustee or director
20$60,000
Betty K FiegenTrustee
Trustee or director
10$36,500
John KrebsTrustee
Trustee or director
10$26,780
Julie BriesTrustee
Trustee or director
10$26,530
Dan BuksaTrustee
Trustee or director
10$26,530
Mark L ConnaughtonTrustee
Trustee or director
10$26,530
Erin DonnayTrustee
Trustee or director
10$26,530
Eugene EvenTrustee
Trustee or director
10$26,530
William MartinTrustee
Trustee or director
10$26,530
Sharon MackTrustee
Trustee or director
10$26,530
Elizabeth McFarlaneTrustee
Trustee or director
10$26,530
Susan PereiraTrustee
Trustee or director
10$26,530
Kelly PinchertTrustee
Trustee or director
10$26,530
Michael SchusterTrustee
Trustee or director
10$26,530
990 for the year ended December 31, 2023: 32 people
NameTitleHours / weekCompensation
Greg TemplePresident
Officer
40$836,825
Mark WalsworthEVP - Chief Marketing Officer
Officer
40$824,191
Christopher NowotarskiGeneral Counsel/Corporate Secretary
Officer
40$664,944
Joni KazmierczakVP
Key employee
40$257,038
John HillebrandSVP
Officer
40$235,166
Geno TurekVP
Key employee
40$226,139
Michael DeeringVP
Key employee
40$225,017
Tim PowersDirector
Key employee
40$218,426
Lawrence MillsVP
Key employee
40$185,698
Holly NaumanDirector
Key employee
40$176,395
Nelson LundChief Actuary
Key employee
40$176,013
Matt KorienekSenior Product Actuary
Key employee
40$169,233
Angela JordanChief Underwriter
Key employee
40$165,616
Matt TaylorSenior Field Manager
Highest-paid employee
40$165,591
Wayne ShogerFacilities Engineer
Highest-paid employee
40$141,875
Jerome SweeneyManager
Highest-paid employee
40$130,609
David HuberChairman of the Board/Trustee
Former
40$101,150
Rodney OligmuellerChairman of the Board/TrusteeT
Trustee or director
20$100,729
Betty K FiegenTrustee
Trustee or director
10$31,000
Ronald FreundTrustee
Trustee or director
10$30,693
Julie BriesTrustee
Trustee or director
10$26,010
Dan BuksaTrustee
Trustee or director
10$26,010
Mark L ConnaughtonTrustee
Trustee or director
10$26,010
Erin DonnayTrustee
Trustee or director
10$26,010
Eugene EvenTrustee
Trustee or director
10$26,010
John KrebsTrustee
Trustee or director
10$26,010
Sharon MackTrustee
Trustee or director
10$26,010
Elizabeth McFarlaneTrustee
Trustee or director
10$26,010
Susan PereiraTrustee
Trustee or director
10$26,010
Kelly PinchertTrustee
Trustee or director
10$26,010
Michael SchusterTrustee
Trustee or director
20$26,010
William MartinTrustee
Trustee or director
10$10,838

Address and contacts

Address (IRS master file)
355 SHUMAN BLVD, NAPERVILLE, IL 60563-1270
In care of
% JOHN HILLEBRAND
Mailing address (990-N for 2007)
452 Hawes St, New Bedford MA 02745
Principal officer (990 for 2024)
John Hillebrand, 355 Shuman Blvd, Naperville, IL 60566
Principal officer (990-N for 2007)
Ronald L Gonneville, 452 Hawes St, New Bedford MA 02745
Signed the 990
John Hillebrand, Senior Vice President Finance
Phone
(800) 552-0145

Mission

A CENTURY OLD CATHOLIC FRATERNAL SOCIETY DEDICATED TO PROVIDING OUR MEMBERS WITH FINANCIAL SECURITY AND OPPORTUNITIES FOR SPIRITUAL, SOCIAL AND CHARITBALE GROWTH.

990 for the year ended December 31, 2024

Program accomplishments

  • TO PROVIDE COMPETITIVE INSURANCE AND RETIREMENT PRODUCTS TO OUR MEMEMBERS AS A FRATERNAL LIFE INSURANCE COMPANY
    Expenses $102,113,614 · grants $348,534 · revenue $105,771,853
  • FRATERNAL ACTIVITIES FOR MEMBERS INCLUDING FEEDING GODS CHILDREN ETC.
    Expenses $2,982,142 · grants $348,534

What it must file and when

IRS records say it files Form 990 or 990-EZ. Based on its last return; a smaller organization may file the 990-N. Its accounting year ends in December, so each return is due on the 15th day of the 5th month after that.

Tax yearYear endedDueIRS public records
2025December 31, 2025May 15, 2026Not on file
2024December 31, 2024May 15, 2025990 on file
2023December 31, 2023May 15, 2024990 on file

IRS record

EIN
36-0879870
Tax-exempt status
501(c)(8): Fraternal beneficiary society
Donations deductible (Pub 78)
Organization other than a public charity or private foundation; Group exemption; Fraternal lodge, deductible only for charitable purposes
Exempt since
1940
Accounting year ends
December
Files
Form 990 or 990-EZ
Group exemption
0072 (208 member organizations)
Assets (IRS master file)
$1,212,528,934
Income (IRS master file)
$105,771,852

Filing history

FormYear endedRevenueExpensesAssetsReturn
990December 2024$105,771,852$105,444,291$1,212,528,934XML
990December 2023$168,454,127$167,157,575$1,246,730,858XML
990December 2022$132,222,212$131,270,235$1,275,261,661IRS
990December 2021$114,599,440$116,214,255$1,291,586,056IRS
990December 2020–––IRS
990December 2018–––IRS
990December 2017–––IRS
990-N for 2007
Officer: Ronald L Gonneville
December 31, 2007≤ $50,000 receipts––e-Postcard

990-N: the IRS bulk file holds only the latest e-Postcard per organization; earlier years come from archived copies of that file since 2020 and can have gaps (the IRS e-Postcard search lists every one). 990, 990-EZ, 990-PF, 990-T: every e-filed return in the IRS e-file index since 2019; XML for the latest three processing years, amounts from the IRS Statistics of Income extracts before that. PDF copies and determination letters at the IRS (search EIN 36-0879870).

Questions about CATHOLIC ORDER OF FORESTERS

What is the EIN of CATHOLIC ORDER OF FORESTERS?
The employer identification number (EIN) of CATHOLIC ORDER OF FORESTERS is 36-0879870.
Is CATHOLIC ORDER OF FORESTERS tax-exempt?
Yes. The IRS lists it as tax-exempt under section 501(c)(8) since 1940.
Are donations to CATHOLIC ORDER OF FORESTERS tax-deductible?
Yes. It is listed in IRS Publication 78 (Organization other than a public charity or private foundation; Group exemption; Fraternal lodge, deductible only for charitable purposes).
Which annual return does CATHOLIC ORDER OF FORESTERS file?
Form 990 or 990-EZ. Based on its last return; a smaller organization may file the 990-N.
When is the next return of CATHOLIC ORDER OF FORESTERS due?
The return for tax year 2025 (the year ending December 31, 2025) is due May 15, 2026. Form 8868 extends it by six months; the 990-N cannot be extended.
When did CATHOLIC ORDER OF FORESTERS last file with the IRS?
The latest return in the IRS public files is the 990 for the year ended December 2024.
Who is the principal officer of CATHOLIC ORDER OF FORESTERS?
The 990 for the year ended December 31, 2024 names John Hillebrand.
Who are the officers and directors of CATHOLIC ORDER OF FORESTERS?
The 990 for the year ended December 31, 2024 lists 32 people; 32 received compensation from the organization, the highest $746,704 (Greg Temple, President).
How much revenue does CATHOLIC ORDER OF FORESTERS have?
On its 990 for the year ended December 31, 2024 it reported revenue of $105,771,852, expenses of $105,444,291 and total assets of $1,212,528,934 at year end.

Organizations in its group exemption (208)

Other nonprofits in NAPERVILLE

All nonprofits in NAPERVILLE · Illinois